← back to the archive // episode file

Suspect Finally Caught from 2017 Cold Case; Hiding in Plain Sight

#printing#cvs#suspect#print#murder
the transcript auto-captions · entered into evidence

0:00 thank you [Music] hey are you ready to get tripped out with the boys no what's up check this out Delphi Indiana okay a city with uh 3 000 people population okay Township that's a little ass Kitty what that's a joke it Rhymes it Rhymes you're welcome dude you're welcome right in 2017. in 2017 these two girls two teen girls no just keep laughing they were murdered on a hike come on that's not funny that's not funny thing another cheese so this is a tiny town right 3 000 people in this town in 2017 the two teen girls went on hike and

0:51 they were murdered but the case still went cold after five years no suspect how were they murdered I mean it was a hiking killing right it's hard to tell if you're in the woods and ████ we have to know the nature of the murder I think they were just like stabbed or something so they're they're just hiking and ████ yeah man you know maybe that makes it even crazy it's like a whodunit it's like those it's like knives out when it's like a smaller group of people Everyone becomes a suspect but do you think it's even people in the town well that's the question so here's what happened so that's back in 2017 right so the two girls they're they're uh you know they've been murdered their families are trying to look for answers they even though the case went cold and they're not even working out that much the family's still trying to find some kind of solution they go and print photos of the girls at like the local

1:44 CVS and you know try to post around try to look and ask questions for the town and eventually uh this year a suspect was found and charged what who was it is a family member is it random or here's a hint I I said it when I just described what happened it was a family member family member nope oh I missed it I wasn't listening did they kill each other no it was a nice fight it's two it's in what I just said it's two sisters that had a knife fight no they didn't kill each other the Killer is is in what I just said it's it's they went to go print photos from the print guy the Xerox copy machine guy was the guy printing the photos at CVS

2:34 how how did they know they caught I don't know they didn't say how how they figured out the case but they caught him and they realized he was the CVS guy oh my God the same guy that was on that hike at that time who killed him you know what my sadistic ass was like I was gonna I was gonna crack a stupid joke because it's like whoever smelt it dealt it right it's like if I were to murder somebody and try to get away with it I might also be the guy printing the photos to pretend you know what I mean like why aren't you guys finding this murderer he was wait he was the one that was printing it on his own no he works at CVS and then the parents came in and said print this out but they didn't know that that was the guy can you put these spots and he's like you gotta Stop Printing these men you're never gonna catch them he got arrested and they named the suspect the parents saw it and went

3:24 that's the ████ CBS guy there is a God isn't that the most torturous thing you can do to the Killer is just you have to be confronted with their parents who consistently if I knew that was the killer I would do this just to ████ with them I would keep and I'd just be like man I don't know where I just have no idea where to draw it out no idea like this is happening so like uh and then I'll just be like he was such a good person you would you wouldn't go you wouldn't be like man if I ever found that person I'd probably like after phalanges one by one dip their ████ body in acid while they're still alive you wouldn't do ████ like that no because I don't want to scare my suspects too much to where they run away and they're gonna be they're gonna know they're gonna know yeah one of those people would be like hey you know what

4:14 like you seem like a nice guy come over for like tea I want to show you old photos you should come over and then they'll be like oh no all right RX time next time it's time and then you come by and then you could be like dude I made you some cookies because you've been printing out all these things thank you so much you know find out that he was hiking with them or he was just so happening like yeah I want to know the motive they don't know they just know that at that time the girls disappeared and were killed that this guy's the suspect they just know that that maybe he was just out there trying to kill somebody they just got the dude so it's it's that's why because CVS isn't paying him that well and he's like I'm mad it's like ████ this ████ justifying again

5:07 what do you mean for profit no he didn't murder them he's just frustrated you know he doesn't look like a printer though he looks like a murderer just printing stuff imagine that guy he does look like us he does I was was picturing like a teen kid printing photos so you know when you're at TVs you don't need a person to actually print it yeah there's just a person working there that will tell you like oh you just got to do this and then you know it's a machine right yeah he he actually has his farm tech license so he has like a dark room and all that ████ works at CVS he like does the pharmacy oh Pharmacy yeah how he was able to kill both like he and then it's a stabbing right ah I don't know and then the other one could run away and he looks like a fat dude okay fine so is he gonna be able to chase after the other one like how did he get both

5:57 that's what I'm curious about probably just a big strong guy from the bat he's from the back and he's no no two knives next did they ever find a murder weapon no necks two next Who's Next it actually doesn't even say what the weapon was it just says oh you could have shot him murdered while hiking yeah he could have shot him both and empathize for one second because this is kind of ████ up that feeling that the parents must have had after the fact because you wouldn't go and print the photos you would print the photos recognize and Associate it have that guy in your database for whatever reason subconsciously and and then they had to have a moment of realization imagine that moment of realization where you were literally face to face in interaction it's not like a suspect that's like why would you do this to my daughter it's like I interact this

6:48 ████ I could have killed the ████ that killed my kids that ████ must be ████ crazy wait so he's just a suspect but they didn't prove that he did it or oh but I know he did it that ████ did the case is not over he wore an orange jumpsuit he did it but after five years of no suspect and they're and they picked this guy I'm sure it's a pretty good ████ lead I wonder yeah how that came to be like how how they investigated and they're like oh it was this ████ the time to go through all 3 000 people it's just process of elimination was it you no it wasn't you no it wasn't you maybe would that guy just went hell no that's you interesting why are you so desperate that guy yo that is crazy though I was thinking about that that's why like if it I when I go to the woods I'm always armed because I don't know like

7:40 well if it was if it's not a human it's an animal okay that's true you know so like your weapons of choice when you go Joe's armed right now guys is this ████ surprising he has weapons everywhere how many weapons you got right now with he hit one two there you go oh that is a weapon probably don't even even need to take it out actually it's just dramatic whoa we don't want to get demonetized here I know man we can't be showing up Contraband oh you're the judge I'm the judge he's Thor bro yeah so it is crazy that uh in a town of 3 000 people like for that a case to go if you got a town that small I feel like things like public hangings are still cool yeah basic thing is this guy is also married with a daughter of his own oh like he's just a regular Dude too see that's what

8:31 it's like so fast not fascinating but like you really want to know motive you really want to know like fascinated dude it sounds scary dude a little fascinating because it's like I don't know I think that's why people are so fascinated with murder in general people are fascinated with them curious look at Dahmer dude who literally says stop saying faster what about saying look how fascinated I am withholding the guy that was uh Mary and his wife was like wow this took me by surprise uh Peggy Bundy I think it's that one Ted Bundy Ted Bundy yeah I think it was that one hey oh the girlfriend well like yeah he had a girlfriend and he was like no he was but it and then but the but the weird uh phenomenon was every time they fought he took out his anger on a girl outside oh interesting so every time they fought he

9:21 would go go out to like cool down or whatever and then he would commit that crime where he would murder a woman all this stuff so his girlfriend they've been with each other for so many years and she was just like no a great dude but like we never yeah his Outlet yeah wow he took it out on other women or that was just his like kind of cover-up Alibi because he got another human being that's like there's no way I was with him the whole time I'm the same type of girl that he would do this to you know that could be his whole mask yeah yeah if you're that if you're that wild and you can do it that long and you're that successful at it it's fascinating he was gay you know what I mean yeah that's true you know when there's psychologists that try to look or like criminal

10:11 psychologists that try to look into the mentality of a lot of killers and they try to pinpoint the root in which like things sort of went wrong do you believe that some people are just innately ████ up I don't I think that it is Nate uh nurture oh it's always nurture I think that you can be wired a certain way but it's your environment to to make you have a vendetta toward the world so like your story if you had a bad story like you're not just born with a desire to just murder a ████ ton of people I don't believe that I believe in most of these cases there is a story of trauma there is a story of whatever because no one talks about the bright side of people with these conditions that might be diagnosed with being psychopath or whatever right but when you're in the

11:02 right environment you channel that in a way that's like extreme sports you might be a CEO of some sort yeah you might not be a killer but you do have the condition but you do have human um what do you call it Choice like you choose to make the decision of expressing yourself through murder this this might be a little ████ up but I really feel like Jeffrey Dahmer just wanted love too he keeps on saying because he admitted he admitted because he admitted like he was like I don't know why I was doing it but my mother left and I I wanted to he's like oh I don't I just want to be with them he keeps saying that yeah at least for now there's no story where there is a serial killer who's had a great perfect childhood and nothing was wrong and then all of a sudden they're just murdering

11:52 tons of people there's always some sick twisted ████ that happened to them or their stories kind of ████ up and then they started going down this path like they might be predisposed with their lifestyle and how they grew up is like the thing that sets them off but that's what I'm saying there might be when you say predisposed it might be like 10 nature yeah and like 90 Nursery you know what I mean like I do think that just as much as like uh we don't necessarily always explain why uh this is the biggest person that ever grew and this is super tall or like this person grew only this you know what I mean if there's that much difference and variation in things that are beyond our control there's gotta be a little bit of that too in a different way you know I think people are wired in a way where like hey uh you don't have a guilty conscience when you kill like there's that's that's true right but then yeah

12:44 it's also up to them to decide what to do with this ability but imagine because if you're super tall like you were saying you you could like Anthony is very tall if he goes through doors he has to you know like that down every time but I don't wanna if it's my house I don't want to duck down every time that's why it's like if I my empathy is like I don't care about killing people all the time every day I gotta not kill people yeah let me kill people sometimes yeah and it's cool that you're standing up for Jeffrey dahmerman yeah he likes to kill people I think that's why Dexter is so fascinating right because Dexter is like someone who is a serial killer but for Justified means where people go yeah good job [Music] foreign

// end of tape